Physician Assistant Malpractice Insurance: Cost, Coverage & Quotes
All healthcare professionals face the risk of malpractice lawsuits, sometimes even when they aren’t at fault. PAs are no exception. PA malpractice insurance pays for your legal defense, settlements, and damages awarded to the patient if you’re at fault for an adverse outcome. It affords you peace of mind to focus on quality healthcare.
Here’s a plain guide from an independent agency, plus free PA quotes.
Do Physician Assistants Need Malpractice Insurance?
Yes, PAs need malpractice insurance to cover the costs of legal claims arising from patient care. Few states require it by law, but most employers and hospitals do, and employer policies have limits, exclusions, or restrictions that leave you personally exposed.
Individual PA malpractice insurance can help protect your license, income, and professional reputation when a claim alleges negligence, errors, or omissions.
Why Physician Assistants Need Malpractice Insurance
As a physician assistant, you perform a similar job to a physician, i.e., taking medical histories, performing physical examinations, ordering tests, and analyzing test results.
You’re part of a healthcare team, and you’re essential for improving patient outcomes. Your responsibilities may even extend beyond direct patient care.
You may also have administrative duties, such as:
- Maintaining medical records.
- Scheduling appointments.
- Managing inventory.
PAs train in various medical specialties, such as internal medicine, family practice, emergency medicine, and surgery. You can also focus on specific fields like pediatrics, dermatology, or oncology.
Potential Legal Risks Faced by PAs in Their Practice
The responsibility of PAs comes with professional liability risks, and malpractice insurance protects them from financial losses resulting from negligence claims or accusations of errors and omissions.
For example, you may be assigned a task outside your scope of practice and cause harm. In such cases, you may face a malpractice lawsuit and potentially be held liable for damages.
Another scenario in which a claim can arise is when a patient reports a negative reaction to the medication that you prescribed. You’ll be held responsible if an investigation finds that you didn’t take sufficient precautions or follow proper protocols.
Furthermore, as PAs continue to expand their scope of practice and take on more independent responsibilities, they may also face legal challenges related to state regulations and restrictions.
For instance, some states impose laws regarding PA supervision by physicians, and noncompliance bears legal consequences. Here’s more on physician assistant malpractice insurance and why you need it.
How Often Do PAs Get Sued?
Physician assistants (PAs) are sued significantly less often than medical doctors (MDs). According to data from the National Center for Biotechnology Information via PubMed, PAs average roughly 1.4 to 2.4 malpractice payment reports per 1,000 PAs, compared to 11.2 to 19.0 per 1,000 physicians.
What Does PA Malpractice Insurance Cover?
Professional Plans provides the following coverage for physician assistants, helping you find peace of mind so you can do what you do best: caring for your patients:
- Coverage options up to $2million
- Full Consent to Settle Claims
- Legal fees paid in addition to Liability Limits
- HIPAA Defense
- License Defense
- General Liability Available
- Portable coverage- take your policy with you if you change jobs
- Wage Loss and Expense
- First Aid Reimbursement
- Medical Payments
- Sexual Misconduct Expense
- Risk Management Services
While your employer may have insurance in place already, chances are, there are a few limitations within the contract or policy.
But what does this mean for you?
Well, if you are faced with a lawsuit, then you’ll likely be paying out of pocket for some of the claim, even if you win the case.
It’s essential to provide your own financial protection, too, allowing you to focus on your job without the added stressors of lawsuits, expensive fees, and other obstacles, should they come your way.
How Much Does Malpractice Insurance Cost for Physician Assistants?
PA malpractice insurance costs vary depending on several factors, such as:
1. Experience Level
Like all professions, the more experience a PA has, the less risky their practice is perceived to be. PAs with several years of experience and no history of malpractice claims may pay lower premiums than those who are just starting out.
2. Specialties
Some specialties attract higher risks and demand higher insurance premiums. For example, a PA working in surgery may have a higher premium than one working in dental care.
3. Geographic Location
Insurance companies also consider the location where a PA practices when determining the cost of coverage. In areas with a high volume of medical malpractice lawsuits or expensive settlements, insurance rates may be higher.
County and state laws also affect the cost of malpractice insurance. For instance, some states cap the amount that can be awarded in medical liability cases, causing lower insurance rates.
4. Coverage Limits and Deductibles
Did you know the coverage amount you choose can affect your insurance costs? The more they offer to pay for your troubles, the more expensive your premiums may be.
Similarly, deductibles also affect insurance rates. A deductible is the amount you, as a PA, must pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage begins. Higher deductibles often attract lower premiums but may cost more when a claim is made.
5. Claims History
Insurance companies also consider a PA’s history of malpractice claims when determining coverage rates. If a PA has had multiple claims in the past, they may be considered more risky to insure and, therefore, have higher premiums.
In contrast, a clean claims history attracts lower premiums over time, with insurers perceiving you as a low-risk client.
6. Claims-Made vs. Occurrence
The type of policy you choose also shapes your premium.
Claims-made policies typically cost less upfront because they only cover claims that are both reported and arising while the policy is active. The tradeoff is that once the policy ends, you lose coverage for past incidents unless you buy extended reporting (tail) coverage. That raises a common question: who pays for malpractice tail coverage when a PA leaves a job or switches insurers? The answer depends on your employment contract, so it’s worth clarifying before you sign.
Occurrence policies, on the other hand, cover any incident that happens during the policy period, even if the claim is filed years later. They cost more, but they’re easier to manage when changing jobs or insurers because no tail coverage is needed.
Factors That Affect Physician Assistant Malpractice Insurance Costs
| Factor | Raises Cost | Lowers Cost |
| Experience Level | Limited clinical experience or being newly qualified | Several years of clinical experience and a clean claims record |
| Specialty | High-risk specialties, such as surgery and emergency medicine | Lower-risk specialties, such as primary care |
| Geographic Location | Practicing in states or regions with high malpractice claim frequency and costly settlements | Practicing in areas with lower claim frequency and settlement costs |
| Coverage Limits and Deductibles | Higher coverage limits and lower deductibles | Lower coverage limits and higher deductibles |
| Claims History | Previous malpractice claims or multiple reported incidents | No previous malpractice claims |
| Policy Type | Occurrence coverage, which generally has higher upfront premiums | Claims-made coverage, which generally has lower initial premiums |
Note: These are general insurance pricing trends. Actual premiums vary by insurer, state, specialty, policy terms, and individual risk profile.
Are PAs Covered by Their Supervising Physician’s or Employer’s Policy?
As said before, it depends, but PAs are rarely ever fully covered by their supervising physician’s or employer’s policy. The sad truth is that employer policies protect the employer first, and PAs aren’t automatically on the physician’s policy.
Employers offering you some malpractice insurance is a way to insulate themselves from liability, not necessarily to provide you with comprehensive personal protection.
Before relying on an employer-provided policy, review:
- Whether it’s occurrence-based or claims-made,
- Whether you would need to purchase tail coverage after leaving the position
- What the coverage limits are
- If the employer needs your consent to settle a claim
- Whether the policy covers your work outside that specific job, including volunteer or moonlighting work
We discuss this topic in more detail in this post: ‘Employer vs. Individual Malpractice Insurance for Physician Assistants.’
What to Look for in the Best PA Malpractice Insurance
1. Comprehensive Coverage
The best malpractice insurance policies should provide comprehensive coverage that includes both defense costs and indemnity payments in case of a claim.
Defense costs include:
- Legal fees,
- Court expenses,
- Expert witness fees.
Indemnity payments cover any damages awarded to the plaintiff.
2. Tail Coverage
PAs leaving or transitioning from one practice to another should consider purchasing tail coverage. This type of coverage extends your policy beyond its expiration date and protects you from claims made after you have left your previous job.
3. Good Reputation of the Insurance Company
You want to work with a reputable insurer with a credible reputation for reliably covering PAs in the past. Before deciding, look into the insurer’s financial stability, claims process, and overall customer satisfaction.
4. Adequate Limits
When choosing malpractice insurance, make sure the policy provides adequate limits. These limits define the maximum amount the insurer will pay on your behalf.
As a PA, you want a policy with high enough limits to protect you from any potential lawsuits or damages.
5. Consent-to-Settle Clause
Let’s say a claim is made against you, and you think it’s unfair and unfounded. Your insurers think it’s cheaper to settle with the claimant, but you think settling would be an admission of guilt and ruin your reputation.
Consent-to-settle clauses allow PAs to accept or decline settlement offers. It may be better to go to court, argue your case, and clear your name when you’re not at fault.
6. License/Board Defense
Professional licenses are crucial to your livelihood, and a complaint to a licensing board can jeopardize that. These professional boards have judicial powers to investigate complaints, impose sanctions, suspend licenses, or revoke them entirely.
Board defense expenses accumulate quickly, and you need experienced legal counsel to navigate:
- Hearings,
- Deadlines,
- Discovery requests.
Insurance pays your defense expenses against malpractice claims.
7. Portability
Would you like to work extra shifts, provide telehealth services, and take locum tenens assignments? You can’t run such gigs safely without portable malpractice insurance. You want to check if that contract excludes:
- Moonlighting,
- Independent contractor work,
- Out-of-state practice,
- Services performed outside your primary employer.
Requirements can vary by carrier, specialty, and licensing jurisdiction.
How to Get a Physician Assistant Malpractice Insurance Quote
You can easily get a quote for malpractice insurance as a PA in the following three steps:
1. Research and Compare Insurers
Start by researching different insurers who offer malpractice insurance for PAs. Consider their reputation, financial stability, claims process, and customer satisfaction.
Compare each insurer’s coverage options and limits to settle on the best value.
2. Fill Out an Application Form
Once you have chosen an insurer, complete an application form with basic information about yourself and your practice, including your:
- Education,
- Work experience,
- Certifications,
- Any previous claims or lawsuits.
Provide accurate answers in your application to receive valid quotes and avoid any potential issues.
3. Receive and Review Your Quote
Only after submitting an application will insurers evaluate your situation and send you a quotation. Take the time to review it carefully.
Always seek answers to any arising questions or concerns by asking your insurer for clarification. If everything looks good, you can purchase your PA malpractice insurance policy.
Why Professional Insurance Plans Is Best for You
At Professional Insurance Plans, we’ve insured over 3000 healthcare professionals nationwide since 1991. We have experienced firsthand how vastly different the risks involved are for various healthcare roles.
That’s why we offer specialized coverage that’s tailored to the unique needs of different PAs. These plans differ from physician liability insurance because they cover two entirely different roles with different risks.
We understand that shopping for, negotiating, and buying insurance is challenging, so we simplify it for you, starting with a physician assistant malpractice insurance quote. We top it off with customizable malpractice insurance plans and competitive pricing.
PA Malpractice Insurance FAQs
1. Do physician assistants need their own malpractice insurance?
Yes, though it’s not mandated in many states, you need it for the coverage it offers for unintended errors, omissions, or allegations of negligence. Employer-provided coverage may offer some protection, but it often leaves gaps.
2. How much is malpractice insurance for a PA?
It depends on specialty, location, claims history, and coverage limits. For example, a PA working with a generalist doctor has less risks than a colleague working under a cosmetic surgeon or another working in a busy emergency room.
3. What is the best malpractice insurance for physician assistants?
The best policy is one that matches your scope of practice, specialty risk, and employment arrangement. You may also be wondering if professional liability insurance the same as malpractice insurance?
4. How often do physician assistants get sued?
PAs average roughly 1.4 to 2.4 malpractice payment reports per 1,000 PAs. While that’s much lower than the rate that physicians face, it’s still often enough to warrant individual malpractice coverage.
5. Who pays for tail coverage when a PA leaves a job?
It depends on the employment contract and the policy type. Employers may provide tail coverage, require the PA to purchase it, or offer it as a negotiated departure benefit.
6. Is PA malpractice insurance tax deductible?
Yes, you can deduct the premiums that you pay for malpractice insurance as a business expense if you’re self-employed or responsible for your coverage.